Hmmm....reading digests from the last week or so, here's a
few comments:
Happy belated birthday, you old bird! And William, take a
bow!
Ross Macdonald, once he finally figured out what he was
trying to say, just
kept saying it over and over, sort of like Chandler's
criticism of
Hemingway. Seems Macdonald himself was going through a bit of
a real life
missing daughter job, and he worked it out through fiction.
But his theme,
of a familie's past crimes catching up with the present, was
a good one,
and the fact he wrote essentially the same book over and
over, after The
Galton Case, shouldn't be held against him. Think of it as
endless
improvisations on a good riff. Or, just because Roll Over
Beethoven sounds
like Johnny B. Goode doesn't mean Chuck Berry couldn't
rock.
Given all that, though, The Drowning Pool was pre-Galton
Case, and was
really (IMHO) Macdonald trying to find his own voice, while
still trying to
out-Chandler Chandler. His early books are often overwritten,
and downright
sloppy at times, but I always liked The Drowning Pool, mostly
because of
that scene at the end from which the book gets its title (why
do writers
forget it's OK to get a little action in?). Seems I remember
a pretty
savage mauling of Macdonald in an Armchair Detective several
years ago,
where the author tore apart (I think) The Moving Target,
pointing out
Macdonald's mistakes and excesses (I'll post the issue number
once I'm back
home, if anyone's interested).
And James, I don't think comics are necessarily off-topic.
There's a
current one called Jinx by Brian Bendix (I think-I can't
check) that's
might stylish, about a female bounty hunter, a couple of
low-grade career
criminals and a lot of missing loot. And Max Collins and
Terry Beatty keep
promising to bring back Ms. Tree, a dame that could show V.I.
and Kinsey a
few tricks. In fact, I think Ms. Tree is probably the
hardest-boiled female
eye in town, tracing her roots, not to Marlowe and Spade, but
doing an end
run around them to Mike Hammer and straight back to Race
Williams.
Oh, and way back when there was power, I managed to catch
Jackie Brown.
Great acting serves the caper plot well, but anyone expecting
Pulp Fiction
II will be yelling rip-off! I liked it, and I think it bodes
well for
Tarantino that he's willing to make a film geared for adults,
rather than
the average moviegoer. It was nice to see a flick on a
Saturday night in a
theatre not packed with 25-going-on-14-year-old yahoos.
Someone give Robert
Forster another movie! And that DeNiro guy was pretty good,
too. Maybe
someone should give him a movie, too.
Kevin Smith
Web Guy for The Thrilling Detective Web Site
For info, mailto:kvnsmith@total.net
"Well, I'll have some rotten nights after I've sent you
over/But that'll
pass..."
- Seeing the Real You at Last (Bob Dylan, via Dashiell
Hammett)
#
# To unsubscribe, say "unsubscribe rara-avis" to
majordomo@icomm.ca.
# The web pages for the list are at http://www.vex.net/~buff/rara-avis/.