On this week's reading: First, for anyone looking for a copy
of
_Hard-Boiled_, I got a remaindered hardback for 10 bucks
yesterday. The
store said they have one more (at Alexandria location) and
they would
probably mail it: Olsson's toll free is (800) 989-8084,
e-mail
ols1239@aol.com I got my copy at the Alexandria, VA location
which is
(703) 684-0077.
I thought the Leigh Brackett story was pretty good, if a
little
predictable. The opening descriptions were particularly nice
(the fire
on the neck--is it blood? No diamonds, etc.) James Reasoner
notes that
she has enough material for a novel. The exposition of
substories
(e.g., the Harding brother murdered at steel mill) becomes a
less
appealing thumbnail substitution for the dramatic rendering
that might
have taken place in a novel (one of the issues discussed in
the
first-person v. third-person debate; along the same lines, we
might
discuss the virtues of novel vs. short story; I much prefer
the novel).
One last point on this story: the good cop is particularly
marked as
ethnically italian (Carmen Prioletti) fighting the presumably
Irish
Hickey. What's that about? Why does Brackett make this
choice?
I think the Helen Nielsen story was the much stronger of the
two. I
liked its prose and simplicity--and it's quite a bit more
bleak. One
mark of its strength is how affecting it is, even as it is
predictable
(as James Reasoner notes). I think the reader's heart leaps
with false
hope even as he or she knows the hope is false (sort of like
you think
Desdemona is going to revive in Othello--early
hard-boiled--even though
you know she doesn't). Finally, James notes that he
sympathizes with
the farmer, but I even found myself sucked in by
Morrell--especially
when he talks about how he has used "college sharpies" to
make HIS
money--a class-incisive story swallowed up by this
sharpie.
Doug Levin
#
# To unsubscribe, say "unsubscribe rara-avis" to
majordomo@icomm.ca.
# The web pages for the list are at http://www.vex.net/~buff/rara-avis/.